Contouring of Subsurface NAPL
Accumulations with Surface Radon Measurements
Marcelo F. Ortega, Environmental Geochemistry Group, E.T.S.I.
Minas Madrid, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, Alenza
4, E-28003 Madrid, Spain, Tel: +34 913 366 992,
Fax: +34 913 366 948
Jerónimo E. García-González, Environmental Geochemistry
Group, E.T.S.I. Minas Madrid, Universidad Politécnica de
Madrid, Alenza 4, E-28003 Madrid, Spain, Tel: +34 913 366 993,
Fax: +34 913 366 948
Luis F. Mazadiego, Environmental Geochemistry Group,
E.T.S.I. Minas Madrid, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid,
Alenza 4, E-28003 Madrid, Spain, Tel: +34 913 367
005, Fax: +34 913 366 948
Eduardo De Miguel, Environmental Geochemistry Group, E.T.S.I. Minas Madrid,
Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, Alenza 4, E-28003
Madrid, Spain, Tel: +34 913 366 992, Fax:
+34 913 366 948
Traditionally, the task of locating and quantifying
subsurface accumulations of NAPLs present in the
subsurface at contaminated waste or industrial sites has
involved drilling and core-sampling the vadose zone and
installing wells to collect samples of groundwater and
free-phase products if present. Drilling, coring, pumping,
preserving, transporting and analyzing solid and liquid
samples are all expensive operations. If preliminary
information regarding the location of the source zone and
of the plume of contaminants is lacking or is
insufficient, there is a clear risk that time and money
will be wasted in drilling and installing wells in the
wrong locations, where they will yield useless or
misleading data. Non-intrusive, time-efficient surface
techniques, i.e. soil vapor analysis, geophysical methods
and radon measurements (emanometry) can be used to
minimize this risk. The results of field experiments show
that the activity of 222Rn is significantly reduced above
pools of NAPLs due to radon’s preferential partition
into the organic phase, and that the boundaries of the
free phase plume are marked by an increase of radon signal
above local background levels due to the accumulation –
and subsequent decomposition – of uranium in the
reducing environment around hydrocarbon pools. Since the
diffusivity of radon in the subsurface is higher than that
of most volatile organic compounds, emanometry is
considerably less sensitive to depth and soil
heterogeneity than surface soil-gas measurements, and is
applicable even when the amount of organic vapors reaching
the ground surface is very low or non-existent. All of the
above suggest that radon monitoring can be effectively
used to draw the surface trace of NAPL accumulations for a
wide range of pollutants even in difficult geologic
environments.
The Value of Characterizing the
Hyporheic Zone at a Variety of Contaminant Sites
Mark Emmons, Resource Laboratories, LLC,
124 Heritage Avenue #10, Portsmouth, NH
03801, Tel: 603-436-2001, Fax: 603430-2100
Richard S. Behr, Maine Department of Environmental
Protection, Station 17, Augusta, ME 04333, Tel:
207-287-6828, Fax: 207-287-7826
Troy Smith, Maine Department of Environmental Protection,
Station 17, Augusta,
ME
04333, Tel: 207-287-7786, Fax: 207-287-7826
Brian Beneski, Maine Department of Environmental
Protection, Station 17, Augusta,
ME
04333, Tel: 207-287-4858, Fax: 207-287-7826
In
New England
, groundwater flow paths generally terminate in the
vicinity of surface water bodies.
Groundwater discharges often manifest themselves as
distinct springs or as wetlands adjacent to a stream or
river while in other instances the groundwater may
discharge directly to the stream through the underlying
sediments. This
zone of discharging groundwater is called the ‘hyporheic
zone.’ Characterizing
the chemistry of this discharging water provides useful
information about upgradient contaminant sources and
impacts to surface water bodies.
Using a push point ™ sampler, an inexpensive
sampling device, one can assess the chemistry of
discharging groundwater.
We discuss hyporheic zone characterization data
from several contaminant sites to illustrate a variety of
reasons why it is a useful component of a site
investigation. We
present data from two sites where characterization of the
hyporheic zone provided invaluable data about upgradient
groundwater quality before installation and sampling of
monitoring wells.
Evaluation of the hyporheic zone can also optimize
subsequent monitoring well placement.
In one example, groundwater data from a small
network of bedrock monitoring wells demonstrated the
existence of a contaminant plume associated with a sludge
filled quarry but limited funds precluded the downgradient
delineation with additional bedrock wells.
However, the subsequent chemical characterization
of the hyporheic zone along a small brook identified
groundwater discharges more 1200 feet from the source.
Perhaps most importantly, historically
investigators have largely relied on surface water samples
to assess the impact of discharging contaminant plumes.
Characterization of the hyporheic zone may reveal
the biota residing in the stream sediments are exposed to
a very different chemical environment.
We present data from two sites where the hyporheic
zone water quality data clearly demonstrates the surface
water chemistry yields little about the chemical
environment within stream sediments, the portion of the
stream in which benthic organisms live.
Utilizing LNAPL Laboratory Testing
Methods to Evaluate Mobility for Site Characterization
& Selection of Remedial Alternatives
Brandon J. Fagan, PG, LSP, Haley & Aldrich, Inc., 465 Medford Street, Suite 2200,
Boston,
MA 02030, Tel: 617-886-7400, Fax: 617-886-7791
Michael Brady, PG, PTS Laboratories, Inc.,8100 Secura Way
,
Santa Fe Springs,
CA
90670, Tel: 562-907-3607,
Fax: 562-907-3610
Current progress by the EPA, API, RTDF and a wide array of
researchers over the last 20 years have developed tools
and models to characterize the potential mobility of NAPL,
more specifically LNAPL for petroleum impacted site
assessment. Conventional methods and modeling for the
potential mobility has relied heavily on indirect
indicators of LNAPL plume stability and mobility in soil
utilizing well information, fractional concentration of
organics in soil characterized with EPA methods,
saturation profile modeling and other.
Laboratory test alternatives under consideration
for direct quantification of LNAPL mobility in soil
coupled with lines of evidence for the site are reviewed
for practitioners use ranging from comparison of field
saturation relationships to residual saturation capacities
of the soil to methods to obtain results with more direct
methods that include capillary pressure drainage
relationships, analysis of the relative permeability of
the LNAPL to flow in soil in the presence of groundwater,
and methods for measurement using unsteady state constant
flow testing and water flood pore volume exchange methods
to quantify LNAPL drainage and imbibition. Methods of
analysis such as these reinforce field observations and
develop the understanding of the migration potential of a
plumes source and boundaries with more direct quantitative
procedures to support risk based approaches for land
reuse. Further,
for feasibility analysis of site treatment, they can be
instrumental in quantifying the potential performance of a
remedial technology for LNAPL containment, recovery, and
evaluation of the impacts of amendment and thermal
modifications to LNAPL.
No-Purge Groundwater Sampling
Evaluation at the
Massachusetts
Military Reservation
Matthew Greenberg, CH2M HILL, 318D East Inner Road, Otis ANG Base, MA
02542-5028, Tel: 508-968-4670
x 2230, Fax: 508-968-4916,
Email: mgreenb2@ch2m.com
Nigel Tindall, P.G., CH2M HILL, 318D East Inner
Road, Otis ANG Base, MA 02542-5028, Tel: 508-968-4670
x 5620, Fax: 508-968-4916,
Email: Nigel.Tindall@ch2m.com
Rose Forbes, P.E., Air Force Center for
Environmental Excellence, 322 East Inner Road, Otis ANG
Base, MA 02542-5028, Tel:
508-968-4670 x 5613, Fax:
508-968-4476, Email: rose.forbes@brooks.af.mil
The no-purge groundwater sampling methodology enables the
passive collection of a groundwater sample from a discrete
interval within a monitoring well screen without the
pumping or purging required by conventional techniques
such as low-flow sampling.
No-purge sampling relies upon the natural advective
movement of groundwater through an open wellscreen. After
sufficient time has elapsed for the sampling device to
stabilize, the resulting sample is considered to be
representative of the aquifer conditions immediately
adjacent to the wellscreen. The primary advantage of using
the no-purge technique is the cost savings associated with
reduced sampling time, reduced equipment and materials,
and elimination of purge water when compared to sample
collection through conventional methods using pumps.
The feasibility of integrating the no-purge
sampling methodology into a large groundwater monitoring
program was evaluated at the Massachusetts Military
Reservation (MMR) where at least 1,500 monitoring wells
are sampled each year. With this many wells to sample, the
cost benefits of integrating this technology into the
monitoring program could be considerable.
Two types of no-purge sampling devices were tested
and evaluated: the passive diffusion bag sampler (PDB) and
the HydraSleeveÒ sampler. A
series of “side-by-side” sampling tests were performed
that evaluated the performance of: (1) PDBs versus the
traditional low-flow pump sampling techniques; and (2)
PDBs versus HydraSleeveÒ
samplers. The
testing consisted of a comparison of the analytical data
generated using each sampling technique, a qualitative
assessment of the useability of the sampling devices, and
an evaluation of the potential cost savings of using
no-purge techniques against the conventional low-flow pump
methods. In
addition, the evaluation reviewed the overall benefits and
limitations of the no-purge samplers tested against the
traditional low-flow pump sampling techniques currently
being utilized at the MMR.
The Trace Metals and Natural
Radionuclides in Seawater from around Oil Field Offshore
Platforms. Environmental Study
Sergio F. Jerez Veguería, Universidade Federal Fluminense – UFF, Instituto
de Química, Dpto. Química Analítica, Outeiro de São João
Batista s/n, Campus do Valonguinho - Centro - Niterói -
RJ - 24.020-150, Brazil, Tel: +55 (21) 2629-2142,
Fax: +55 (21) 2629-2143, Email: sfjerez@rdc.puc-rio.br
José M. Godoy, Pontifícia Universidade Católica do
Rio de Janeiro, Depto. Química. Rua Marquês de São Vicente, 225 -
Gávea,
CEP - 22453-900.
Rio de Janeiro
- RJ –
Brazil
and Instituto de Radioproteção e Dosimetria, Comissão
Nacional de Energia Nuclear. Av. Salvador Allende s/n -
Jacarepaguá , CEP - 22780-160. Rio de Janeiro
- RJ –
Brazil
, Tel: +55 (21) 3411-8073, Email: jmgodoy@rdc.puc-rio.br.
Offshore oil and gas production can cause a potential impact
to the marine environment. Large volumes of aqueous waste
are produced during oil and gas production and, normally,
these are discharged, following treatment on the platform,
to the sea. In this produced water the high concentrations
of metals and naturally occurring radioactive materials
(NORM) are often found and this contaminants are being
introduced or have entered the sediment and water column
near production sites. In this work the offshore seawater
samples from the Bacia de Campos oil field were analyzed
for As, Ba, Cd,
Co, Cu, Mn, Mo, Ni, Pb, V,
Zn, U, 226Ra, 228Ra and 210Pb. In this paper, a
procedure for multielement determination of Cd, Co, Cu, Mn,
Ni, Pb, V and Zn in seawater using Inductively Coupled
Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) is described. The method
involves chelation of the metals onto a iminodiacetate
resin (Toyopear® AF Chelate-650M) in a column with the
simultaneous matrix removal. U and Mo determinations were
performed by ICP-MS with ultrasonic nebulizer in
quantitative mode (external calibration) using 205Tl as
internal standard. The samples (salinity ³
3.5% p/v) were diluted 1:100 with Milli-Q water and
acidified with HNO3 sub-distilled. Arsenic was determined
by HG-ICP-MS. Using twenty liter of seawater, after
radiochemical separation, the 210Pb was determined by beta
counting of 210Bi, and 226Ra and 228Ra were determined by
gross alpha and beta counting rate using a proportional
10-channel low-level proportional counter. In general,
except for the sampling point immediately at the place of
discards of produced water, the trace metals and
radionuclides concentrations in the analyzed samples of
seawater around de platforms are in agreement with the
expected values for unpolluted water.
Focusing on the Collection of
Representative Data
John H. Sohl, III, Columbia Technologies, 1448 S Rolling Rd, Baltimore,
MD 21227, Tel: 410-536-9911, Email:
jsohl@columbiadata.com
Ned Tillman, Columbia Technologies, 1448 S Rolling Rd,
Baltimore
,
MD
21227, Tel: 410-536-9911, Fax: 410-536-0222, Email: ntillman@columbiadata.com
Many site investigations rely on expensive analyses of a
limited number of samples.
This process has proven to be a very costly process
requiring multiple visits to a site.
It has also proven not to be an efficient way to
assess risk or bring sites to closure.
This is largely due to the fact that the limited
data are not fully representative of the entire site and
therefore leads to a poor understanding of site
conditions.
EPA is encouraging investigators to take a far greater number
of measurements to ensure they get adequate coverage of
heterogeneous site conditions.
These measurements don’t have to be expensive
analyses. The
data can be collected using direct sensing tools like the
continuous MIP, CPT or LIF sensors, or field analytical
measurements.
The great advantage of using real time field measurements is
that a field investigation can be more flexible collecting
only data that focuses in on better characterization and
risk assessment needs.
The biggest challenge on projects where a lot of
data are collected is the real time processing and
utilization of the data in directing the field
investigation.
SmartData Solutions© is an integrated approach that allows
all types of field measurements to be processed
immediately so the entire technical team can participate
in data review and the optimization of field decisions
without them all having to be on site.
Data from mobile and fixed laboratories as well as
direct sensing measurements are integrated into high
resolution 3D images that can be updated and disseminated
every hour. The
result of this process is a continuously evolving
Conceptual Site Model that is posted to a secure webpage
that all the parties can access and discuss.
This process results in a better supported and
better tested site characterization and provides a more
reliable data set for risk assessment.
Cleanup Standards and Goals for
Urban Fill Soil
Bill Swanson, Vice President, P.E., LSP, CDM Inc., 50 Hampshire
Street, Cambridge,
MA 02139, Tel: 617-452-6274, Email: swansonwr@cdm.com
Pam Lamie, MPH, CDM Inc., 50 Hampshire Street,
Cambridge, MA
02139, Tel: 617-452-6311, Email: lamiepo@cdm.com
Understanding background
contaminant concentrations in urban soil is critical to
expediting and economizing cleanup at urban/brownfield
properties. The objective of this paper in support of a
poster presentation is to examine metals and polynuclear
aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) common to urban soil and to
identify natural soil concentrations, historic fill soil
concentrations and those concentrations that clearly
indicate a site of release of contaminants or an outlier.
This effort will detail common historic fill background
concentrations versus distinct release concentrations or
outliers in a form that can be readily used by a site
assessment professional to screen urban sites.
The objective was
accomplished by using approximately 5,000 samples of urban
soil available to the authors and primarily subjecting the
data to statistical analysis. The database available to
the authors has generally been derived from sites in urban
New England and, in particular,
Boston
. Moreover, findings elsewhere in terms of background
concentrations of these contaminants in soil will also be
provided to enhance the poster presentation. The mean
values derived for key parameters were incorporated into
risk assessment calculations to determine if the defined
urban fill soil was also a significant risk. By
incorporating a large data set into an analysis, the
authors developed a tool that can readily be overlaid by
an analyst using a smaller, site specific data set
particular to a given property or site under
consideration. This overlay approach using a short list of
key parameters provides the analyst with a powerful tool
to determine how many data points, if any, occur beyond
normal urban soil limits. A ninety (90) percent cut off
point was selected as an allowable maximum and an upper
confidence limit on the mean was calculated.
The metals addressed include arsenic, beryllium,
chromium, nickel and lead.
PAHs are represented by benzo(a)pyrene and
dibenzo(a,h)anthracene.
Can Fractured Bedrock Sites be
Characterized Sufficiently to Recommend Viable Remedial
Technologies?
Jim Vernon, ENSR, 2 Technology Drive,
Westford,
MA
01886, Tel. 978-589-3075, Fax 978-589-3100, Email: jvernon@ensr.aecom.com
Mark Kauffman, ENSR, 2 Technology Drive,
Westford,
MA 01886, Tel. 978-589-3071, Fax 978-589-3100, Email: mkauffman@ensr.aecom.com
Patrick Haskell, ENSR, 2 Technology Drive,
Westford, MA
01886, Tel. 978-589-3095, Fax 978-589-3100, Email: phaskell@ensr.aecom.com
Despite advancements in biogeochemical data and geophysical
tools, the distribution and transport of groundwater
contaminants through crystalline bedrock fractures remains
challenging to conceptualize. Groundwater flow can be restricted to a discrete
subset of connected bedrock fractures, while contaminant
transport may not be well correlated with the degree of
fracture-zone hydraulic activity.
While characterizing hydraulic interconnectivity
between source areas and receptors and between individual
wells is a desired component of a conceptual site model (CSM),
scale issues may prevent the identification of specific
contaminant pathways or the prediction of contaminant
concentrations throughout a site. This predicament extends
into the identification of remedial technologies and the
common lack of confidence in recommending a truly viable
option.
This particular case study has been the subject of prior
papers, demonstrating the sophisticated array and
sequencing of investigatory tools applied to developing
the CSM. The
site is coastal Maine, dominated by shallow metavolcanic and intrusive bedrock,
with little overburden material.
Groundwater flow is controlled by bedrock
fractures, lithologic contacts, or faults.
CVOCs discharged on site from past operations have
been detected in wells at concentrations up to 4,000
micrograms per liter, with a heterogeneous and somewhat
unpredictable and unexplainable spatial distribution.
Investigations have included:
geologic and fracture mapping, surface and borehole
geophysical surveys, whole-well and packer sampling,
monitoring well installation and angled coring, rock
matrix analysis for CVOCs, rock mass characterization,
soil sampling, photolineament analysis, borehole radar
investigation, hydrophysical logging, packer sampling, and
water level monitoring.
A combination of conventional and less
frequently-applied techniques has allowed an assessment of
contaminant transport pathways in the source area, a
refinement of the CSM for the overall site, and a more
direct evaluation of remedial options.
However, despite the use of these tools and
well-executed investigatory program, there are no remedial
technologies that appear to have the potential to restore
aquifer conditions. This
creates a situation where the optimum approach could be to
simply continue protecting receptors from coming in
contact with contaminated groundwater.
This paper critically evaluates what level of
investigation is essential, before such a finding can be
concluded.
Phosphorus Enrichment in Weihe
River
of China
Dr. Jialong Lu, College of Resources and Environmental Science, Northwest
Agriculture and Forestry University, Yangling, Shaanxi
712100, China and Department of Plant, Soil and Insect
Sciences, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA 01003,
Tel: 413-545-2739, Fax: 413-545-3958, Email: ljlll@nwsuaf.edu.cn
or jialong@psis.umass.edu
Dr. Baoshan Xing, Department of Plant, Soil and Insect Sciences,
University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA 01003, Tel:
413-545-5212, Fax: 413-545-3958, Email: bx@pssci.umass.edu
Phosphorus (P) is an essential element for plant growth, but
it also is a key element for eutrophication of water
bodies. The loss of P from agricultural soils leads to not
only reduced utilization efficiency of fertilizers and
high cost of agricultural production, but also to the P
enrichment in surface and ground waters. In this study,
water samples were collected at seven sampling locations
along
Weihe
River
on eleven occasions between March 2004 and March 2005.
Total P (TP), molybdate reactive P (MRP) and total
dissolved P (TDP) of the water samples were measured.
Dissolved organic P (DOP) and total particulate P (PP)
were calculated by the difference between TDP and MRP, and
between TP and TDP, respectively. The results showed that
the average concentration ranges of TP, MRP, DOP and PP in
Weihe
River
were 0.18~1.48 mg P L-1, 0.018~0.38 mg P L-1, 0.019~0.23
mg P L-1and 0.074~1.28 mg P L-1, respectively. The average
proportion of PP (58%) was higher than that of MRP (22%)
and DOP (20%). The data of TP and MRP in this study
exceeded the eutrophication threshold levels (0.1 mg L-1
for TP and 0.01 mg L-1 for MRP). Most likely, P in
Weihe
River
is coming from the agricultural soils along the river
banks, particularly in September due to the amount of
rainfall. Therefore, it is important to have appropriate
soil management to reduce soil runoff, thus, the output of
P to
Weihe
River
.
Top
|