|
|
|
|
| Conference
Program
|
|
Session 2:
Advances in Bioremediation of Contaminated Sediments - II
Integrated
Analytical Approach for Determining Bioremediation
Effectiveness
David B. Ringelberg,
USACE-CRREL, Hanover, NH
Bacterial
Adaptation to PAH Degradation in the Sediments in
Elizabeth River and Lower Chesapeake Bay
Michael T.
Montgomery, Naval Research Laboratory, Washington DC
Verification
of a Model for Contaminant Transport through a Cap
Danny Reible,
Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA
Biogeochemical
Dynamics of Trace-Metals in Wetland Sediments: Field,
Laboratory, and Numerical Simulation Studies
P.R. Jaffe,
Princeton University, Princeton, NJ
Low
Intervention Bioremediation Approaches for Industrial Site
Demolition and New Construction in Deltaic Soils/Sediments
Ralph J. Portier,
Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA
Wetlands
Restoration and Phytoremediation of Surface Water and
Contaminated Sediments
Michael F. Coia, URS
Corporation, Willow Grove, PA
Using
QSAR and QMSA to Predict the Toxicity and Degradability of
Chemicals in Sediments and Water: An Evaluation Using
Quadricyclane and Its Analogs
Joseph P.
Schubauer-Berigan, US EPA, ORD, NRMRL, LRPCD, Cincinnati,
OH
Integrated
Analytical Approach for Determining Bioremediation
Effectiveness
D. Ringelberg, and M. Reynolds, U.S. Army Engineering
Research and Development Center, and A. Peacock,
University of Tennessee/Center for Biomarker Analysis
As part of a recent USACE effort, dredged harbor
sediment contaminated with polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons (PAHs) was removed from the Milwaukee
Confined Disposal Facility near the South Milwaukee
Harbor, WI, and examined for in situ biodegradative
capacity. By integrating analytic chemistry, microbiology,
and molecular biology techniques, the successional
characteristics of indigenous microbiota were determined
during a four-month bioslurry evaluation. Total PAH
concentrations were reduced by 51% in the first two months
of the evaluation followed by only an additional 1% in the
next two consecutive months. The plateau in PAH loss was
preceded by a shift in the microbial phenotype and
genotype toward one conducive to PAH biodegradation
(specifically toward the presene of the Rhodococcus sp. of
bacteria and enzymatic catabolism via aromatic ring
cleavage). A similar approach was taken to examine the RDX
biodegradative capacity of an Arctic soil over a 5 week
period. A significant loss in RDX concentration only
occurred if the soil was submerged under water for the
duration of the study. The reduced environment was then
further manipulated by the addition of alternative e-
acceptors, which induced a change in the in situ
microbial community structure resulting in different rates
and extents of RDX transformation. RDX
transformation/biodegradation occurred at the greatest
rates and extents in the order: iron (in the zero valent
stae) > sulfate > nitrate. Results of these studies
suggest that the intrinsic biodegradative potential of an
environmental site can be derived from the polyphasic
characterization of the in situ microbial
community. The integrated approach outlined above focuses
on the use of "whole-sample" characterization
techniques or direct assays of microbes in their natural
environments, without impacting them during the
measurement process. In addition, these techniques
collectively provide the activity measurements or
phenotypic/genotyic descriptions necessary for defining in
situ biodegradation potentials, which no single assay
can address.
Bacterial
adaptation to PAH degradation in the sediments in the
Elizabeth River and lower Chesapeake Bay
Michael T. Montgomery, Thomas J. Boyd, and Chris Osburn,
Naval Research Laboratory; Julia K. Steele and Catherine
V. Badger, Geo-Centers, Inc, Washington, DC.
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons are a prevalent source
of toxicity in estuarine sediments. Chronic exposure to
petroleum hydrocarbons may result in alteration and
adaptation of the natural bacterial assemblage in these
sediments. During five research cruises from November 1999
to August 2001, surface sediments were sampled at 11
stations in the Elizabeth River and Lower Chesapeake Bay.
Bacterial production and mineralization of sentinel PAHs
(naphthalene, phenanthrene, and fluoranthene) were
measured in sediment subsamples using radiotracer
additions. Ambient PAH and lignin concentrations were also
measured in the sediment for comparison with the
microbiological parameters. We found that PAH
mineralization rates typically varied by four orders of
magnitude over the survey site with the lowest
mineralization occurring at the offshore station and the
highest mineralization in sediments that were chronically
exposed to petroleum hydrocarbons from groundwater
intrusion. Phenanthrene and fluoranthene mineralization
rates were frequently higher than those measured for
naphthalene. Ambient total PAH concentrations in the
sediments varied from less than 1.0 m g g-1
sediment dry weight to over 13 m g g-1 over the
survey site. The range of values for bacterial production,
PAH mineralization and ambient PAH concentrations were
similar to that measured in both the Charleston Harbor and
the Upper Delaware Bay/Schuykill River systems. Comparing
PAH mineralization rates to total heterotrophic production
is proposed as a line of evidence for naturally
attenuating sediments.
Verification
of a Model for Contaminant Transport through a Cap
Danny Reible, PhD, PE, and X. Fu, Louisiana State
University
Capping with clean sediments is an effective means of
managing contaminated sediments. A simple analytical model
of chemical migration in caps has been proposed (Reible,
in Palermo et al., 1998) to aid in their design and
evaluation. Due to the long time frames normally required
to evaluate capping effectiveness in the field, a
laboratory study was initiated to test and refine the
model using high precision vertical profiling of toluene
transport in a sorbing cap. Models for both cap
consolidation and chemical transport were considered. The
Corps of Engineers model PSDDF was found to adequately
describe subaqueous consolidation of a cap while the
chemical transport and fate model was found to accurately
describe chemical transport during and subsequent to
consolidation. Experimental results and model comparisons
will be presented and the capabilities of the current
version of the model reviewed.
Biogeochemical
Dynamics of Trace-Metals in Wetland Sediments; Field,
Laboratory, and Numerical Simulation Studies
P.R. Jaffe, S. Xu, and J.H. Choi, Princeton University
Mobility of trace metals in wetland sediments is
controlled by the vertical redox profile that develops in
these sediments. This profile is determined by the
reactive transport of different electron acceptors in the
sediments. Transport is affected by diffusion and
advection, and for oxygen also the transport through the
roots of wetland plants. Reactions affecting the electron
acceptors include their utilization by bacteria during the
degradation of organic matter. The objective of our
research is to obtain a mechanistically-based
understanding of the dynamics of trace metals in wetland
sediments. The long-term goal is to assess how changes in
either water quality or vegetation affect the
sequestration or release of trace metals in wetland
sediments. For this purpose we are conducting experiments
in the field and laboratory, as well as developing a
numerical model, to gain a better understanding of the
many processes that affect the redox profile in wetland
sediments and the fate of contaminant metals in these same
sediments. Vertical concentration profiles of the key
redox species, as well as that of trace metals, are being
measured using microelectrode techniques. These
measurements are being conducted in a red maple riparian
wetland, as well as in microcosms maintained in a
greenhouse in which red maple seedlings are planted at
different densities. The concentration profiles are being
monitored over several diurnal cycles in the greenhouse,
and will be monitored over different seasonal cycles in
the field. A reactive transport model has been developed,
consisting of a set of coupled, steady state mass balance
equations, accounting for advection, diffusion,
bioturbation and reaction of an organic substrate,
electron acceptors, corresponding reduced species, and
contaminant metals of interest. The model also accounts
for release of oxygen and uptake of nitrogen by plant
roots, as well as flow induced by evapotranspiration.
Model outputs will be compared to the measured
concentration profiles and provide guidance for further
model refinement.
Low
Intervention Bioremediation Approaches for Industrial Site
Demolition and New Construction in Deltaic Soils/Sediments
Ralph J. Portier, Ph.D., Patrick. M. Moore, R.Mark
Conger, Louisiana State University
New industrial construction projects along the
Mississippi corridor often require demolition of existing
structures and subsequent site assessment and remediation
of deltaic soils/sediments and groundwater. This can be a
challenging endeavor that often involves excavation of
site materials and off site transport. New methods are
needed that do not require excavation and that can treat
marginally contaminated sites in place. A remediation
alternative utilizing a biological in situ process
,i.e., biological plugs, was evaluated as a sound, low
intervention strategy. This low intervention, biological
plug strategy was utilized to treat petroleum contaminated
soil, impoundment sediments and groundwater in order to
ready a site for a new construction project. Initial total
petroleum hydrocarbon (TPH) soil measurements revealed
values as high as 5200 mg/kg. Groundwater TPH measurements
revealed concentrations as high as 20 mg/L. The goal of
this project was to reduce these concentrations to that
deemed suitable by state risk assessment standards (2.7
mg/L groundwater). By the end of a 220 day treatment
period, all TPH concentrations had been reduced to
concentrations well below regulatory standards. Soil TPH
and groundwater concentrations had been reduced to non
detect at six of the seven sampling locations. TPH
concentrations at the remaining sampling location was
150±22 mg/kg for TPH soil and 0.15± 0.1 mg/L
TPH groundwater.
Wetlands
Restoration and Phytoremediation of Surface Water and
Contaminated Sediments
Michael F. Coia, URS Corporation and Dr. Laura Carreira,
Applied PhytoGenetics, Inc.
Phytoremediation is presently gaining increasing
technical and regulatory acceptance as an environmentally
sound and cost-effective solution for the in-situ cleanup
of organics-contaminated wetland sediments, surface water
and shallow ground water. The selection and application of
native plant species to phytodegrade organic constituents
of concern represents a successful biotechnology
alternative to conventional site cleanup techniques. While
many phytoremediation applications involve hydraulic
control of ground water plumes using tree stands or
incorporate increased bio-accumulation of metals
constituents from soils requiring subsequent plant
harvest, this paper addresses successful treatment of
specific organic contaminants using proper plant selection
and design of wetland ecosystems. These treatment wetlands
utilize plant-based enzymatic biochemical processes, which
work in concert with indigenous microbial activity to
optimize rhizospheric biodegradation and plant tissue
phytodegradation. The application of proper site design
facilitates the combination of sediment cleanup with
wetlands restoration for increased eco-habitat creation.
The authors have teamed together at numerous sites to
achieve successful treatment of site organics through
monitored phytodegradation in laboratory greenhouse
studies followed by field-scale site demonstrations and
full-scale wetland phytoremediation systems. Data will be
presented from recent projects involving the
phytoremediation of contaminated sediments and shallow
ground water plumes with elevated concentrations of
chlorinated solvents, nitroaromatics and PAHs. These
families of organic constituents are being successfully
treated using engineered wetland phytoremediation systems.
The biochemical kinetics of organics treatment will be
presented as an important criterion for proper plant
species selection. Recent advances in plant assay
techniques along with laboratory greenhouse studies and
field demonstrations allow for optimization of
phytoremediation approaches, and these scientific
techniques will be discussed. Practical engineering,
design and field construction techniques will be
presented, as they are successfully being employed in
wetland phytoremediation systems for organics treatment.
In order for phytoremediation of organics to achieve
widespread application, successful site cleanup projects
will require comprehensive interdisciplinary approaches,
which involve biochemistry, plant molecular biology,
botany, hydrogeology, ecological risk assessment,
engineering and environmental landscape contracting. The
importance of each of these project disciplines will be
discussed.
Using
QSAR And QMSA To Predict The Toxicity And Degradability Of
Chemicals In Sediments And Water: An Evaluation Using
Quadricyclane And Its Analogs
Joseph P. Schubauer-Berigan, USEPA, ORD, NRMRL, Keith
B. Lodge and Subhash C. Basak, University of Minnesota
The National Research Council has examined the
availability of toxicity endpoints for industrial
chemicals and concluded that many of these chemicals lack
even minimum testing. One way of carrying out risk
assessments of chemicals having insufficient experimental
data is by using Quantitative Structure Activity
relationship (QSAR) models and SARs. In this study we
examined the toxicity and degradability of Quadricyclane
and six of it’s analogs selected using Quantitative
Molecular Similarity Analysis (QMSA) to evaluate the
usefulness of this approach for chemical risk assessment.
The degradability of these chemicals was examined in
spiked water and sediments collected from a freshwater and
marine location, under a variety of test conditions (abiotic,
biotic, aerobic and anaerobic). The sediments water used
in the experiments were thoroughly characterized for their
physical, chemical and biological properties (e.g.
salinity, OM content, nutrients, bacterial numbers etc.).
The toxicity of the chemicals was examined using a number
methods of commonly used in the literature for this
purpose (BODs, Microbial Plate Counts, and Microtox). In
addition, a novel new approach was developed using Biolog
Microplates to examine the effect of these chemicals on
substrate utilization patterns of natural microbial
communities from the sampling locations. Results of the
studies indicated that large fraction of the degradation
of Quadricyclane and its analogs occurred primarily
abiotically. The rate of chemical degradation and toxicity
was influenced by the collection site of the exposure
matrix. The chemicals tested resulted in altered microbial
substrate utilization patterns compared with natural
unexposed communities. The results of the degradability
and toxicity studies verified the usefulness of QSAR, SARs
and QMSA for risk assessments of chemicals having
insufficient experimental data.
Top
|
| Past
Conference Programs | Home |
| |
|
|